The Real Obama


By Joe Campbell
November 7th, 2007

There have been a few profiles in the past few days of Senator Obama, timed perhaps to coincide with the beginning of the sprint for the Democratic nomination.  I already posted some excerpts from Andrew Sullivan’s excellent piece and the candidate himself seems to have picked up on the meme himself.  The theme of Sullivan’s piece was that no other candidate had the promise or the potential of Obama and that Obama and Obama alone could truly respond to this unique moment in American history, both culturally within our country and as our representative abroad.  James Traub has a piece that is somewhat more critical in the New York Times Magazine this past weekend.  Traub reports that Obama is supported by most of the Democratic foreign policy elite, aside from a few of President Clinton’s top aides, who support Hillary.  However, among many voters, Traub sees the problem as this:

Democratic voters seem to be torn between the hope of reshaping a frightening world and the fear of being terribly vulnerable to that world.

Traub concludes:

Obama concedes that he has a problem. “We have not fully made our case yet,” he admits. “I think the American people know in their gut that we need significant change, and I think they’d like to believe what I’m saying is possible.” But they need, says this former law-school professor, “a permission structure.” They need to know that they’ll be safe with Barack Obama. Or unsafe with Hillary Clinton.

Two months before the presidential primaries begin, it still looks like a hard sell.

From the Weekly Standard, Dean Barnett reaches a similar conclusion while analyzing Barack Obama’s charisma and personal appeal.  He explains how he researched Obama’s past trying to find some dirt from his years at Harvard Law, but that oddly enough he could not find anyone who disliked Obama.  Barnett finds this extraordinary – for a top student at a top school who won every honor and excelled, graduating magna cum laude would not have aroused significant jealousies and other petty remembrances.

The results surprised me. Regardless of his classmates’ politics, they all said pretty much the same thing. They adored him. The only thing that varied was the intensity with which they adored him. Some spoke like they were eager to bear his children. And those were the guys. Others merely professed a profound fondness and respect for their former classmate…

The people that Obama so thoroughly charmed generally weren’t the charm-prone types. I say the following as a well known Republican partisan–the fact that his classmates so universally held him in the highest regard suggests that Barack Obama may truly be a special person.

Working for the Weekly Standard however, Barnett is forced to conclude:

There’s still time for the man that I’ve heard is the real Obama to emerge. If he does, he’ll be formidable. But time is growing short.

Both Barnett and Traub reach similar conclusions: they both believe that Obama has greater potential than any of the other Democratic candidates; that he is “special”, and extremely intelligent; and that he’s not quite ready.

You might recall I concluded the same thing after hearing him speak at Washington Square Park this September:

What he is missing is something that everyone around him can sense–his audiences, his aides, himself. Perhaps it is a certain resolve to take on the responsibility; perhaps it is a sense of certainty that he will be able to perform the job. What is missing is both obvious and amorphous.

He is missing just this thing. He is not yet ready. But come January, I believe and hope he will be.

8 Responses to “The Real Obama”

  1. VCubed Says:

    The last thing I see is a lack of preparation when I see Obama, live or on video. I don’t look at him through media lenses, though. He seems utterly capable of analyzing complex interlocking issues – better than the rest, actually. He seems capable of choosing knowledgeable advisers and weighing their advice. He has the calm but determined character I want to see with his/her hands on the world’s deadliest trigger, and a sense of humor despite how seriously he takes things -reminds me of Lincoln without the depression, I swear! I’ll be quick to say I’m a volunteer as well as supporter, but I’m also a politics geek, read absolutely everything I find online, follow politics from my political science training and perspective as a female, from multiple minorities (disabled, former single-parent, Latina, now poor from disability). I struggled to get from the ghetto to Stanford U, I know how hard it is and how much you have to still believe in the American Dream to even try. He succeeded far past my accomplishments, though he had more support – a great wife in Michelle and her family! It’s great but at the same time tragic that when I distribute valid policy information when I do outreach, people see Obama’s the choice hands-down. The media won’t share real policies and plans, so read them yourself, at your leisure but before the primaries, at barackobama.com Check out the depth of his Iraq/Afghanistan/Pakistan policies – the MSM won’t break it down meaningfully, anywhere, go figure!

  2. joe@2parse Says:

    I think you miss my point when you say “a lack of preparation”. I think he has a fine grasp of the issues – better than almost candidate out there and possibly better than any. What he seems to be missing is that indefineable “it”. I believe and hope that by January 2008 he can bring it all together.

    In a previous post, I compared what Obama was missing to what Jed Bartlett was missing in an episode of West Wing. The episode delved into the period just before the primaries before the fictional president was elected. Bartlett was cranky and irritable; he was brilliant and a skilled politician, but he wasn’t ready; somehow, Bartlett the person was chafing against the demands of Bartlett the candidate. Bartlett has not quite embraced his destiny, despite the efforts he was putting into the campaign. I think Obama is in this position now. But I think he, almost inevitably, will be ready come 2008.

    Still, I’d take Obama now over any politician running.

  3. Assisted Living Tucson Says:

    certainly like your web site however you have to take a look at the spelling on several of your posts. A number of them are rife with spelling problems and I in finding it very troublesome to tell the reality however I will definitely come back again.

  4. yymovcom87 Says:

    Collection of some of your personal information is essential for completion of some of the functions and activities of this Website. We will, if it is reasonable or practicable to do so, also collect your personal information directly from you. For instance, the collection of your personal information may happen when you[url=http://www.yymov.com]电影天堂[/url].

  5. creation site web maroc et referencement site internet maroc avec optimisation top 10 pas cher Says:

    La meilleure solution pour reussir votre r?f?rencement et positionner votre site web parmis les tous premiers resultats des moteurs de recherche sur des mots-cles fortement concurrentiels et g?n?rez un fort trafic parfaitement cible, avec une reelle strategie de promotion et de communication, est de l’optimiser top 10 et le rendre aimable par les moteurs de recherche.

  6. Lucio Says:

    This tends to be a streaky defensive passive, since a
    few bad rolls in a row (no dodges) could spell death.
    Bobby: Your films have become known for having such dynamic fight sequences and with Ninja
    II has some amazing fighting as well. However, other regions of the world,
    too, have their own martial arts stories to tell.

  7. JoJorr Says:

    Section 1021 and 1022 have been called a violation of constitutional principles and of the Bill of Rights .

  8. GoodManAEmive Says:

    I ordered an dissertation about from them recently.
    The support team helped me to prefer the right-wing type and hurriedly found me a writer. It wasn’t urgent so I didn’t plague less it, but tranquil it was delivered on every now and I didn’t composed
    force to query quest of a revision. Seems like it’s Worthless disquisition editorial a honourable ceremony!

Leave a Reply