[digg-reddit-me]Closely related to the previous theory of the financial crisis – that Goldman Sachs did it – is the more generalized version of this idea – that the financial sector itself – whether through political donations, lobbying, corruption of politicians, respect, fear, or any other means at their disposal – was able to demand and receive undue influence over the political processes affecting them.
Since Ronald Reagan took office in 1980, the financial industry has been growing more quickly than the rest of the economy – whether because of this or as a result of this, politicians of both parties have given the industry about every policy they wanted. The financial industry began to feel its oats when a cultural revolution swept America – the Reagan Revolution – which removed the various moral stigmas from money and profits just as the 1960s had from sex. Reagan also instituted several policies which served to concentrate wealth (thus enlarging the financial sector) and removing regulations. He cut taxes – especially for the wealthiest; he instituted a de facto Bretton Woods II agreement in which the savings of East Asia were transferred to America, thus enlarging the financial sector further and decimating our manufacturing sector; he ran massive deficits, thus super-charging the economy – from which the financial sector was a main beneficiary; he deregulated various industries thus allowing private enterprises to capitalize on the investments of the public in them; he reduced regulations overall, especially those on the financial sector.
Bill Clinton came into office with various plans to help out the middle class – to pass a stimulus bill, to tackle health care – but was forced by an unruly bond market to back off. Bob Woodward quoted Clinton realizing the power of Wall Street a few days into office:
You mean to tell me that the success of the program and my reelection hinges on the Federal Reserve and a bunch of fucking bond traders?
But Clinton came around and designed an agenda that would win Wall Street’s approval. He brought down the deficit – running surpluses even. He reformed welfare. He pursued free trade agreements – especially NAFTA. The Committee to Save the World – consisting of Treasury Secretary Robert Rubin, Assistant Secretary Lawrence Summers, and Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan (with an assist from Timothy Geithner) organized emergency interventions committing taxpayer dollars to help Mexico, the Asian markets, Russia, and domestic markets with the collapse of Long Term Capital Management in order to keep the markets stable and growing. By the end of his presidency, Clinton was a major proponent of deregulatory measures – signing the repeal of the New Deal era Glass-Steagall Act, forbidding the regulation of derivratives, and allowing off-balance sheet accounting. All of these changes greatly benefited the financial sector and were much sought after by the industry.
And then of course came further deregulation under George W. Bush and his proposal of various housing initiatives under the rubric of an Ownership Society. The deregulatory fervor was probably best symbolized by the efforts of the Office of Thrift Supervision (OTS) to bring more financial institutions under its authority. (Regulators were funded based on what companies they oversaw, so the various regulators began to compete to be more lax.) The head of OTS brought a chainsaw to the photo-op in which the heads of the various regulatory agencies attacked a stack of paper representing bank regulations to demonstrate their commitment to reducing oversight. As Simon Johnson wrote in The Atlantic regarding these many causes of the financial crisis:
[T]hese various policies—lightweight regulation, cheap money, the unwritten Chinese-American economic alliance, the promotion of homeownership—had something in common. Even though some are traditionally associated with Democrats and some with Republicans, they all benefited the financial sector.
His thesis is essentially this:
In its depth and suddenness, the U.S. economic and financial crisis is shockingly reminiscent of moments we have recently seen in emerging markets (and only in emerging markets): South Korea (1997), Malaysia (1998), Russia and Argentina (time and again). In each of those cases, global investors, afraid that the country or its financial sector wouldn’t be able to pay off mountainous debt, suddenly stopped lending. And in each case, that fear became self-fulfilling, as banks that couldn’t roll over their debt did, in fact, become unable to pay. This is precisely what drove Lehman Brothers into bankruptcy on September 15, causing all sources of funding to the U.S. financial sector to dry up overnight. Just as in emerging-market crises, the weakness in the banking system has quickly rippled out into the rest of the economy, causing a severe economic contraction and hardship for millions of people.
But there’s a deeper and more disturbing similarity: elite business interests—financiers, in the case of the U.S.—played a central role in creating the crisis, making ever-larger gambles, with the implicit backing of the government, until the inevitable collapse. More alarming, they are now using their influence to prevent precisely the sorts of reforms that are needed, and fast, to pull the economy out of its nosedive. The government seems helpless, or unwilling, to act against them.
Top investment bankers and government officials like to lay the blame for the current crisis on the lowering of U.S. interest rates after the dotcom bust or, even better—in a “buck stops somewhere else” sort of way—on the flow of savings out of China. Some on the right like to complain about Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac, or even about longer-standing efforts to promote broader homeownership. And, of course, it is axiomatic to everyone that the regulators responsible for “safety and soundness” were fast asleep at the wheel.
But these various policies—lightweight regulation, cheap money, the unwritten Chinese-American economic alliance, the promotion of homeownership—had something in common. Even though some are traditionally associated with Democrats and some with Republicans, they all benefited the financial sector. Policy changes that might have forestalled the crisis but would have limited the financial sector’s profits—such as Brooksley Born’s now-famous attempts to regulate credit-default swaps at the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, in 1998—were ignored or swept aside.
Whether politicians of both parties deferred to the financial sector because of their massive contributions to both parties or because the financial sector became the leading driver of GDP growth doesn’t really matter.
What’s clear is that when the financial sector wanted something, they got it. They blocked reforms; they got deregulation, free trade agreements, business consolidations, and policies that led to market inefficiences and bubbles they could exploit. The financial sector was pushing virtually every policy which contributed to the economic collapse – and politicians of both parties went along.
1,262 replies on “Theories of the Financial Crisis: Deference to the Financial Sector”
car accident attorneys
Find now my best personal injury lawyer lincoln ne currently available for you now!
marketing agencies
Get started today with the best rated page rankings now available in addition guaranteed to produce results today!
small construction projects
Contract us here for licensed and bonded general contractor that’s available for construction projects and ready to go with top quality. Ask for a bid today!
attorneys auto accident
Locate here a great personal injury lawyer omaha ne currently in the office now!
Omaha SEO firm
Get going now with the most professional marketing agencies now available in addition reasonably priced today!
prefab metal buildings
Contact us now for licensed and bonded metal building contractors that’s available for construction projects and ready to go at the top quality. Ask for a bid today!
hour hands for clocks
Find here the best quality wholesale clock movements that are on sale and ready for you and plus a great value for ordering today!
best london boroughs for families
Get a great design for the best relocation agent that are available and now in stock and reasonably priced for today only!
social marketing strategy
Get started today with the most professional email marketing that are available in addition guaranteed to produce results today!
get redirected here
Get a great design for professional mls london that are available and now in stock iadditionally reasonably priced for today only!
auto crash lawyer
See Here a great accident injury attorney currently in the office now!
this content
Get services for professional professional relocation services that is available and in stock and reasonably priced for today only!
best steel building contractor
Get in contract here for licensed and bonded metal building erectors that’s available for construction projects and ready to do your job at great prices. Ask for a bid today!
general contractors
Contract us here for professional metal building contractors currently available for construction projects and ready to do your job at the top quality. Ask for a bid today!
search ranking firm
Get started now from the best rated search ranking consultant that will be available in addition reasonably priced today!
useful site
Get today the top professional injury attorney currently present for you now!
Discover More Here
Get going now with the best video search engine optimization that will be available in addition provides a good ROI today!
Omaha SEO services
Get started now from the best rated search ranking specialist that will be available in addition reasonably priced today!
design builder construction
Get in contract here for top quality tenant improvements contractor that are available for construction projects and ready to go at great prices. Ask for a bid today!
news
Get services for the best london business relocation currently available and now in stock iadditionally on sale for today only!
affordable family areas in london
Get today professional how to move to london that is available and in stock iadditionally at a great value today only!
Check This Out
Get a great design for professional move it london that are available and in stock iadditionally at a great value today only!
how to build your own building
Contact us now for licensed and bonded design build firms currently available for construction projects and ready to go with top quality. Ask for a bid today!
auto injury law
Locate here the geatest omaha attorneys that’s available for you now!
best places to live near london with good schools
Get a great design for the best relocation services uk currently available and in stock iadditionally at reaspnable prices today only!
concrete construction
Contact us now for licensed and bonded commercial building contractor that are available for construction projects and ready to do your job at the top quality. Ask for a bid today!
social media packages
Get here expert facebook advertising local business currently taking on new clients and reasonably priced now!
attorneys automobile accidents
Find now the geatest car accident personal injury attorney currently in the office now!
click for info
Get started today with the best rated social media marketing now available and guaranteed to produce results today!
list marketing
Get started today with the best rated site optimization that will be available and guaranteed to produce results today!
read more
Get in contract here for licensed and bonded metal building erection that are available for construction projects and ready to go at great prices. Ask for a bid today!
social media agency
Profit from amazing social media for local businesses currently open for service and reasonably priced now!
clock movement
Find here the best quality wholesale clock parts currently on sale and ready for you and a reasonabe value for ordering today!
moving to london with a dog
Get today the best london home searcher that are available and now in stock iadditionally on sale for today only!
best universities in london
Get a great design for professional relocation services that’s available and now in stock iadditionally at a great price for today only!
Clock kits and dials
Buy now the best quality clock kit parts currently on sale and ready to ship and a great value for ordering today!
Recommended Site
Get today the geatest auto accident attorney that’s available for you now!
social media marketing pricing
Profit from expert facebook for local business currently open for service and on sale now!
auto accident lawyers nebraska
Locate here a great auto accident attorney currently present for you now!
clock parts manufacturing
Buy now awesome clock parts that are on sale and ready for you and a good value for ordering today!
content writing
Get started today with the most professional wordpress Marketing now available in addition an awesome value today!
motor vehicle accident lawyer
Get today my best car accident injury attorney currently available for you now!
web optimization
Get started today with the best Marketing firm that will be available and reasonably priced today!
best metal building contractor
Get in contract here for top quality general contractor currently available for construction projects and ready to go at the top quality. Ask for a bid today!
DIY clock hands repair
Find here awesome clock kit that are on sale and ready to ship and a good value for ordering today!
read review
Increase caash flow top quality paper billing services available today and getting you results now!
this content
Save cash top quality print to mail service available today and getting results now!
Clock repair parts
Buy now awesome clock parts that are on sale and ready for you and a great value for ordering today!
More about the author
Get a great design for professional london business relocation currently available and now in stock and at reaspnable prices today only!
prefab metal buildings
Contact us now for top quality Metal Buildings that’s available for construction projects and ready to go at great prices. Ask for a bid today!