[FCC Commissioner Robert McDowell at a Tech Policy Summit. Picture by TechPolicySummit used under a Creative Commons license.]
[digg-reddit-me]With some new information, I’m adding to the timeline I created to demonstrate the significance of FCC Commissioner Robert McDowell’s comments on net neutrality (which is also a useful link to check out if you’re unfamiliar with the Fairness Doctrine) a few days ago.
The situation:
The Politics:
Obama is in favor of net neutrality.
McCain thinks it’s all confusing ((His exact quote is: “I go back and forth on the issue.)) and claims he doesn’t know what his position is (though he has made definitive statements opposing it.)
The Democrats are generally in favor of net neutrality.
It has not been a big issue for Republicans, but a few have come out against it (see Ted Stevens.) The conservative base hates the Fairness Doctrine though with a passion.
Since the idea occured to them: Big internet companies want to charge more for customers to access certain internet sites, or to allow certain sites to have priority and to slow down others, and in general to assert control over internet content.
October 2007: The Progress and Freedom Foundation, a think tank funded by companies opposed to net neutrality, publishes a report explaining that a good way to attack net neutrality is to call it “The Fairness Doctrine for the Internet (PDF).”
Spring 2008: Internet providers begin experiments with tiered pricing and other anti-net-neutrality practices.
After McCain secures Republican nomination: He begins to rake in large sums of money from AT&T, the US Telecom Association, Verizon, and other companies opposing net neutrality.
June 2008: A Republican Congressmen introduces a bill to outlaw the Fairness Doctrine (which has been illegal since the 1980s).
Later in June 2008: A conservative reporter publishes a story which alleges that Nancy Pelosi is considering reinstating the Fairness Doctrine.
August 12, 2008: FCC Commissioner, Robert McDowell, says that net neutrality could lead to the regulation of political speech on the internet, as if it’s the Fairness Doctrine for the internet.
The Drudge Report publicizes the speech with the scare headline:
FCC Commissioner: Return of 'Fairness Doctrine' Could Control Web Content...
Now: Conservative talk radio hosts are talking about how net neutrality is the Fairness Doctrine for the internet. (I heard Steve Marlsburg, a bete noir of this blog, who is so old he probably still calls the internet the world wide web ranting on this subject on his show yesterday.) Conservative bloggers are jumping on the bandwagon.
Next week, McCain plans on releasing the details of his Technology Policy which is reported to be “market-oriented.”
Then for my pessimistic speculation…
These conservatives begin to raise the issue in attacks on Obama, liberals, etcetera. Progressives and liberals defend net neutrality.
And then: Independent-minded people and journalists who haven’t been paying attention to this issue finally notice now that conflicts are arising. Journalists cover the issue giving “both sides” and independents throw up their hands, unable to pick a side.
And: Conservatives mount a campaign attacking Democrats. Even those conservatives who support net neutrality are silent because they’re happy for any issue on which they can hit Democrats and which they can use to fund raise.
Finally, January 2009: After the election, Democrats attempt to pass net neutrality legislation. A grass-roots structure has been created to oppose them, and many Republicans have publicly committed to oppose it. An obvious policy choice that should have bipartisan support becomes a struggle to enact.
(On a hopeful note, I think this is a fight the Democrats and supporters of the internet can win.)
This is how public opinion is manipulated. This is how our political system is corrupted as the obvious and clear policy is shrouded in spin and the consensus is replaced by deliberate polarization.
…
Matt Stoller of OpenLeft is more sanguine about the effects of this campaign to tar net neutrality:
Now, the question is not substantive, it’s whether this campaign will work to persuade people that up is down, that black is white. I don’t think it will.
But what I think Stoller is missing is that this propaganda campaign does not seem directed to the public at large, but at conservative activists. The Fairness Doctrine is not something that gets the blood of the average American boiling. But it does evoke a Pavlovian response among conservative activists and right-wing radio listeners.
And although these groups are not large enough to force their way, they are large enough to derail the political conversation and make it harder to enact this obvious policy. Even if some do realize they are being manipulated, many are willing to go along with the party-line and take the necessary positions to gain power.
All of which points to one thing: without Barack Obama as president, net neutrality may not have the necessary support.
384 replies on “‘The Fairness Doctrine for the Internet’ is a Conservative Strawman”
saintcroyheet
orlando magic 47 nba hwc bissau snapback cap royalblue gold red mens nike sb blazer mid shoes prada men wallet 2015 nike free 3.0 flyknit wiggle yellow michael kors leather continental wallet a buon mercato adidas tubular shadow maschio bianca
kwon alexander 58 jersey city
nike raptors 10 demar derozan black nba swingman city edition jersey nike free 5.0 high tops nero under armour curry 4 green germany jordan 5 neroout for vendita oakley sunglasses models xc houston rockets cap
tarabzouni
2014 15 real madrid 2 varane away pink soccer long sleeve shirt kit nobis heritage parka
reprebates
mulberry alexa bag oak nation moncler coat bloomingdale discount liquors ray ban tech aviator mulberry daria clutch purple haze adidas porsche typ 64 wei脽 blau parajumpers gobi femme beige talon
bonodescuento
womens nike kobe 12 orange germany ugg classic mini short nike free run 9 mens nike air huarache light grey black diamond red snapback nike air max 90 hyperfuse white
vinagebarber
nike free trainer 5.0 v baltimore orioles 19 chris davis orange jersey white womens nike hyperdunk 2015 flyknit low shoes burberry cashmere giant check scarf lunarglide 6 cheap looking free run 2 rouge et noir
hommes nike air max 2014 bleu violet
v neck polo t shirts for hombres preston smith washington redskins youth limited nike jersey white cheap nike free 4.0 womens silver kd 7 lebron 12 cp3 nike air huarache hommes rouge queen ray ban rb3025 aviator sunglasses gold brown polarized
royphelps
prada tote pink queen louboutin sandals sale uk mackage jacket discount usa tory burch laptop bag gold purple mens new balance 996 shoes mackage kay fur trim down coat
uheita
bon march茅 nike tanjun racer femmes rouge prada baroque round sunglasses nike free run 3.0 v6 womens orange black michael kors selma black tote bag adidas zx 900 womens white silver kansas city royals jersey los reales
yufnsyb
red silver mens adidas springblade pro shoes 35 authentic grant hill detroit pistons jersey mens adidas nba purple throwback 1995 all nike roshe run high cut mennns asics gel kayano 21 svart s酶lv nike air flight 89 negro magnet gris rojo amarillo ray b…
talentbschool
air jordan 11 womens orange latest nike free run emporio armani eagle belt mackage winter jackets sale date adidas trx runner emmanuel lamur 59 jersey youth
conradtillard
adidas pr酶dator bl氓 and orange outfit nike air max 95 femminile verde bianca nike roshe run flyknit herre for salg nike mens dion lewis game white road jersey tennessee titans nfl 33 nike air zoom structure 18 flash herren laufen schuh nike flyknit air…
cremontana
red silver womens nike blazer high shoes air jordan leather hat nike hyperdunk 2015 mid mens silver red adidas yeezy boost 350 kinder braun gelb nfl nike buffalo bills 85 charles clay royal blue backer pullover hoodie chicago bulls michael jordan hoodi…
asics gel kinsei 4 gr酶n juice
limited nike camo youth jarius wright jersey nfl 13 carolina panthers rush realtree nfl dee ford womens blackcamo 55 kansas city chiefs nike salute to service t shirt reebok insta pump fury og hvit svart womens adidas nmd runner orange spain nike air j…
slipoverfx
adidas turbo boost white flyknit lunar 2 heel strike ua clutchfit force new colorway nike free 3.0 studio dance femmes training chaussures nike giants 34 shane vereen whitepink stitched limited rush fashion jersey grey gold womens nike free tr fit shoe…
kidtokidboise
nike womens free og 14 br running shoe laces ohio state bar hat nike lunar tr1 all black nike air max 1 svart cyber hvit nike womens donald trump navy blue rush pride name number new england patriots nfl 45 t shirt 2014 15 chelsea fc 26 terry home socc…
gaeconomics
air max 95 premium tape all black adidas superstar 2 light blau mens asics asics gel kinsei 2 yellow gold ray ban justin unisex reebok gl 6000 white nike roshe run flyknit multicolor
yenrof
nike air force 1 puerto rico sko coach bleecker duffle bag walmart air max ultra htm nike air max tavas leather grey all red versace belt mackage bag girl guides
apconcierge
speckled nike roshe run ebay adidas mesh running shoes black ferragamo belt with silver buckle mackage tan leather jacket mens puma ferrari shoes in pakistan nike dallas cowboys 9 tony romo blue limited kids jersey
maxcologne
fake black hermes belt prada handbags br2244 original leather pink christian louboutin boots sale mackage womens kerry coat website tory burch flats size 6 nike zoom structure 19 femmes jaune
nike zoom winflo 2 kvinners oransje gull
jordan kicks 2018 nike womens jonathan jones game navy blue home jersey new england patriots nfl 31 ralph lauren pony polo brun gr酶nn nike mercurial superfly mens grey blue prada circle sunglasses nike air max 1 2015 women
myfaccia
herren asics asics gel kayano 20 rosa orange dam盲nner nike lebron 12 grau gr眉n nike zoom pegasus 31 flash kvinners l酶ping sko off nike air max 90 femmes remise mennns nike air max 95 salg uk nike darwin vert gris
emanmoon
hermes chain bracelet prada messenger qr odes louboutin shoes harvey nichols mackage kenya leather jacket sizing office tory burch brown ankle boots nike free 5.0 ext hyper blue
bishoplitman
air jordan 1 university red unblocked new adidas shoes coming out dwyane wade bulls swingman jersey oakland raiders 15 michael crabtree olive 2017 salute to service limited jersey polo ralph lauren slim fit long sleeve polo shirt white nike free run wo…
tubomet
lebron 14 black ice key womens new balance navy white 996 trainers travis kelce nfl jersey oakland raiders 15 michael crabtree olive 2017 salute to service limited jersey polo ralph lauren slim fit pima cotton crew neck jumper nike free run 2 junior gr…
femmes air max 90 hyperfuse violet blanc
jordan horizon nike jordan nike air jordan 6 retro qs infrared heaters nike zoom ascention bl氓 hvid ray ban cats sale nike miami dolphins jersey 28 nolan carroll white jersey limited jersey adidas boost technology
fullcountkbo
nike air force 1 low femminile rosa converse outlet locations nike free 5.0 rot and wei脽 noise elite vinny curry youth jersey philadelphia eagles 75 home midnight green air jordan retro 3 white cement buy 35 authentic grant hill detroit pistons jersey…
frissedenkers
mujeres ralph lauren city polo p煤rpura naranja nike air max 2016 triple negro diamond air max 2017 triple svart qasas nike roshe one id sort mujeres nike sb stefan janoski max todas blanco mens jay ajayi game black nike jersey nfl philadelphia eagles 2…
enucuznevarsa
jordan 3 jaune nike free run 4.0 cortuttio lamp air jordan 3 wolf grigio bg nike air max shake evolve blu rosa lebron 12 arancia and verde flash air max 95 ultra essential noir
mwsuperstore
nike zoom pegasus 32 grey hair red yellow womens nike kaishi shoes chicago bears starter hat blue womens nike air yeezy 2 shoes air jordan 1 retro gull medal match nfl blake bortles youth limited black jersey 5 jacksonville jaguars nike therma long sle…
atppest
new balance 993 herre guld new era nfl knit hats uk chords kobe 11 black space for sale dam盲nner nike roshe run gr眉n rot curry one negro and amarillo light nike air max 95 green spain
kd 8 ext mens nike
mennns nike air max sko on salg ray ban glass lens sunglasses oakley chicago bears b hat retro jordan 13 pink and grey for sale nike air max dynasty trainers mujeres oakland raiders boonie hat
lapthelakes
air max 2014 blu and arancia nike free flyknit 3.0 dam盲nner grau himmelblau nike air max 2019 green uk 2013 nike mujeres lunarglide 5 v shield nike air ubiquitous max for sale converse femme all star blanche
odubmusic
air max 90 holographic qs alex lewis 72 jersey xxl new balance 360 womens green nike shox tlx mens grey jordan 3 blue and white cement dolphins stocking hat nyc
gandoza
nike roshe two rose bleu ciel new nike lebron 12 scarpe air jordan retro 9 b酶rn gr酶n lyser酶d dam盲nner nike air force 1 wei脽 rot air jordan reveal svart gr酶nn nike free 3.0 v5 distance bl氓 rims
racquetlady
air jordan 5 v retro wolf grey huaraches jordan og shoes nike air max 97 og qs silber bullet 2017 tacoma mlb jerseys atlanta braves 32 lowe red cool base jerseys pink red womens new nike free shoes nfl pittsburgh steelers color rush limited antonio bro…
aprylhand
mens fendi hat scarf hermes lindy bag price singapore black ferragamo belt black buckle adidas baseline neo womens pittsburgh steelers draft day hat chicago bulls xl logo snapback
coatsfrance
nike free orbit ii sp cool grau oakley radar path sunglasses lenses ltd nike mens dwayne harris limited camo jersey oakland raiders nfl 17 rush realtree nike free flyknit 3.0 femmes gris adidas superstar 3g slide canada adidas superstar sko gull and hv…
bondhuberman
white hermes scarf bmw nobis jacket billig air jordan retro 9 dam盲nner gold cheap bvlgari bvlgari necklace rose gold chain with mother of pearl roshe run black sail camo north face womens jackets denali
blogdalata
nike free flyknit 4.0 femminile oro cielo blu air jordan 12 ovo svart hommes nike free run 3.0 v6 tout noir air jordan true flight wolf gris matter nike air max 95 invigor print rosado rojo asics gel kayano 21 femmes chaussures underwear
sitesforu
nike chicago bears 57 jon bostic blue elite jersey ferragamo belt buckle size ray ban rb3025 mirrored lens quality philadelphia phillies baseball hat patterns oakley sunglasses holbrook custom office adidas neo cloudfoam
nike air max classic bw maat 45
under armour curry 4 green germany nike lebron soldier 10 wei脽 grau discount oakley fuel cell safety glasses nike dri fit bucket hat nike womens zoom pegasus 32 sale nike free flyknit 4.0 femmes jaune blanc
air jordan retro 3 hvid royal bl氓
femmes asics gel noosa tri 10 noir argent duke golf hat nike lunarglide 7 femmes rouge bleu nike free og negro hombres womens nike flyknit roshe run red blue dam盲nner asics gel kinsei 5 himmelblau orangen
ritaburton
ray ban wayfarer brown lens women mulberry clutches made on canvas nike free run 3.0 v6 womens for sale parajumpers ugo ugo how to tell a genuine burberry scarf hermes phoenix scarf
nikert
ray ban aviator large classic metal uk mulberry french purse pink coat nike kobe 6 green black canada goose solaris parka navy womens burberry scarf monogram thank prada sneaker beige definition
hatstohair
nike stefan janoski max nero and bianca adidas nmd runner all hvit guys jordan 4 blanco out nike hyperdunk 2015 low hvid lyser酶d nike free flyknit chukka hvid orange air max 2016 svart and gr氓
carlandcodys
nike zoom hyperrev 2016 draymond green a ferragamo belt mackage crossbody envelope gift air jordan 1 of buffalo bills kraig urbik jersey 60 game nike white jersey texas rangers beltre jersey
atemspende
prada bag price uae nike mens kobe xi basketball shoes gianmarco lorenzi boots for sale asics gel quantum 360 2 nike pittsburgh steelers 88 lynn swann yellow game jersey chicago cubs 13 castro gray jersey
enventsurvey
under armour curry 1 low oranger vert nike kyrie 1 rouge rose nike flyknit racer herren gelb herre asics asics gel kayano 20 s酶lv lyser酶d nike air max zero arancia argento femminile nike air max zero grigio rosso
maplebeyond
air jordan reveal gituttio oro nike air max schwarz braun new era oklahoma sooners hat nike lebron 3 noir or femminile air yeezy ii 2 sp max 90 grigio air jordan retro 5 womens white sky blue