Two Methods of Interrogation


By Joe Campbell
October 6th, 2007

The Interrogation of Abu JandelGoofus and Gallant on Torture

In October 2000, Abu Jandal was arrested by the Yemeni authorities in connection with the bombing of the U.S.S. Cole. He was a member of Al Qaeda and had served as Osama Bin Laden’s chief bodyguard. After the attacks on September 11, the Yemeni authorities allowed Ali Soufan, one of eight FBI agents who spoke Arabic, to interrogate Abu Jandal.

The attack was fresh in Soufan’s memory. His friend and mentor, John O’Neil, who had dedicated much of his life to fighting Al Qaeda, had been killed in the attacks. Soufan was justifiably, righteously angry. The Yemeni authorities, not known for their squeamishness, gave Soufan wide latitude in the interrogation. The FBI gave Soufan the directive to identify the hijackers “by any means necessary”.

Despite the fact that Abu Jandel refused to cooperate with Soufan at first, Soufan remained respectful. Abu Jandel would rant about the evils of America–the single country, he believed, that was most responsible for the evils of the world. As an additional complicating factor, like many Al Qaeda members, Abu Jandel had been trained in counter-interrogation techniques. He agreed to those facts which Soufan knew and denied everything else. He tried to portray himself as a good Muslim who had at one time flirted with Al Qaeda.

This stonewalling lasted for several days. Soufan was patient, picking up small details he might be able to use. For example, he found that Abu Jandel was diabetic and the next day brought sugarless wafers and a history of America in Arabic. Abu Jandel read the book quickly and was astonished at America’s history. The very fact of Soufan’s existence–as a knowledgeable Muslim who loved America and was in the FBI–was a challenge to Abu Jandel’s conception of America.

Soufan also found that Abu Jandel was troubled that Osama Bin Laden had sworn fealty to Mullah Omar, the messianic leader of the Taliban.

For five days, Soufan and Abu Jandel debated the theology behind suicide bombing, America’s place in the world, and discussed Abu Jandel’s life. He refused to reveal that he had any significant knowledge of Al Qaeda.

On the fifth night, Soufan brought him a news magazine with graphic photos of the twin towers on fire, photos that brought home the scale of the death and destruction. Abu Jandel had heard that something had happened in New York, but was shocked by the events, and insisted that Bin Laden could never do that–he said it must have been the Israelis, or someone else. Soufan showed Abu Jandel a local Yemeni newspaper with the headline: “200 Yemeni Souls Perish in New York Attack.” “The Sheikh is not that crazy,” he insisted, referring to Bin Laden. Soufan asked him to identify a series of mug shots. Still disturbed by the images of the attack, Abu Jandel was able to identify seven men as members of Al Qaeda, but he still insisted that Bin Laden could not have ordered the attack.
 

Soufan responded that he knew for sure that the people who did this were Al Qaeda. “How? Who told you?” Abu Jandel asked.

“You did. You just identified the hijackers,” Soufan said.

Abu Jandel asked for a few moments alone. When Soufan came back, he offered to help, to reveal what he knew about the structure of Al Qaeda, the locations of hideouts, and plans for escape. “I think the Sheikh went crazy,”Abu Jandel said.

Abu Jandel’s information proved significant in the Afghanistan campaign.

The Interrogation of Ibn al-Shaykh al-Libi

In late 2001 or early 2002, Ibn al-Shaykh al-Libi was captured by Pakistani forces while trying to escape Afghanistan . By the middle of January 2002, he was in US custody. He was one of several high value detainees whose interrogation and detention challenged the limits of what the CIA was willing to do. The Bush administration had just recently authorized “enhanced” interrogation techniques, includes, as revealed by the New York Times in a recent expose, “slaps to the head; hours held naked in a frigid cell; days and nights without sleep while battered by thundering rock music; long periods manacled in stress positions” and waterboarding. According to the New York Times:

With virtually no experience in interrogations, the C.I.A. had constructed its program in a few harried months by consulting Egyptian and Saudi intelligence officials and copying Soviet interrogation methods long used in training American servicemen to withstand capture.

Relatively little is known about the specific techniques used on al-Libi or about his interrogation. It seems certain however that al-Libi was subject to these “enhanced techniques” such as simulated drowning and the rest. Additionally, al-Libi was also transferred for a time to a foreign intelligence service in the rendition program, that began under President Clinton, where he was also physically abused and threatened with torture.

Under pressure and feeling threatened, Al-Libi provided the CIA and other officials questioning him with a wealth of information about planned attacks in Yemen and around the world. Most significant however, al-Libi was the primary source for the faulty pre-war intelligence about Al Qaeda-Iraq links. Al-Libi specifically said that Iraq had been training members of Al Qaeda in the use of chemical and biological weapons, a claim cited by President Bush, Colin Powell, and many others as a justification for the war.

This bit of intelligence, gained by torture and used to justify a war, was found to be false after the invasion.

Torture as a Symbol

These are just two of the most prominent examples of the interrogations of detainees after 9/11. Two examples cannot prove a point. They do illustrate an opinion that is held by many if not most interrogators: torture and other extreme techniques are useful in getting people to talk, but not necessarily to tell the truth. The harder and less television-friendly approach is often the best.

Torture, as a symbol, represents the bankruptcy of the Bush’s administration’s approach to the War on Terror. The decision to begin to torture prisoners was made without public debate of any sort, by distorting current law and common sense, by abandoning America’s long-held positions and values, and without any attempt at resolving questions of tactics or strategy.

The CIA thus began to develop a program that mimicked Soviet techniques America had long condemned–techniques that were not designed to elicit information, but confessions for show trials. While Guiliani, Bush, Cheney, Gonzalez, Addington, Scalia, and others have denied that they endorse torture, they have endorsed “enhanced interrogation techniques” inflicting physical and psychological pain short of death or major organ failure. To embrace torture (which is what these men have done) reveals a tactical and strategic deficiency. The focus is on looking tough and on taking postures of violent masculinity even if they are counter-productive.

E. B. White wrote an essay on New York City at the dawn of the nuclear age, saying:

“The city, for the first time in its long history, is destructible. A single flight of planes no bigger than a wedge of geese can quickly end this island fantasy, burn the towers, crumble the bridges, turn the underground passages into lethal chambers, cremate the millions…In the mind of whatever perverted dreamer might loose the lightning, New York must hold a steady, irresistible charm.”

We cannot accept such blunders, such a short-sighted strategy with so much at stake.

My main sources for this information: The Looming Tower by Lawrence Wright, the Wikipedia entry on Ibn al-Shaykh al-Libi, the New York Times’ various articles, and over the course of time, the blog of Andrew Sullivan.

Related articles

Tags: ,

19 Responses to “Two Methods of Interrogation”

  1. Tamer Husni Says:

    Hello webmaster…Thanks for the nice read, keep up the interesting posts..what a nice Friday

  2. Bob the Liberal Says:

    We used to be a country that stood for something, and that was the foundation of our strength.
    We were better than the Nazis, the Soviets, the Japanese… what happened?

  3. CPAinChicago Says:

    This is all too true.

    Pretty much everything here matches with other info I’ve read in reputable places like Time Magazine, etc. …For some reason, I have to say that it never occurred to compare these two cases, but it’s very telling.

    By the way, Senator John McCain, after a lot of brutal torture in Viet Nam wrote in his book that he also talked… And told his interrogators a bunch of names: Of the Green Bay Packers Offensive line…

  4. Support this story on Stirrdup Says:

    Two Methods of Interrogation…

    This story has been submitted to Stirrdup. Your support can help it become hot….

  5. The Beagle Says:

    Things like this further support the slow degradation of America. I don’t see how things like this can go on and have almost no action what so ever been taken on the people who made it happen. Right now some rich politician is chilling in his rather large house in perfect comfort while tons of suspected “terrorists” are stuck in prison without any rights at all. And some of those prisoners might have to be subjected to torture eventually.

  6. Interrogation Methods - Dogpile Web Search Says:

    […] … http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/18/washington/18detain.htm... &#149 Found on Google Two Methods of Interrogation – 2parse/blog A blog about politics, prose, foreign policy, literature, Barack Obama, and liberalism. … Two […]

  7. Travel Russia Says:

    The quality of the info is what keeps me on this site, thanks!

  8. Torture is worse than immoral: it’s tactically stupid - 2parse Says:

    […] use of torture in the War on Terror demonstrated this amply – for example in the contrasting stories of Abu Jandal and Ibn al-Shaykh al-Libi. Share and […]

  9. Democratic Underground - TORTURE gave Bush propaganda to launch Iraq war- - Democratic Underground Says:

    […] intelligence, gained by torture and used to justify a war, was found to be false after the invasion.http://2parse.com/?p=17 Taking this into the equation as to how destructive the use of torture is, would it be too much of […]

  10. Torture Works…For Some Things… - 2parse Says:

    […] seem urgent – beyond the various circumstantial evidence presented. It is known, for example, that Ibn al-Shaykh al-Libi and Abu Zubaydah, each of whom provided key information linking Al Qaeda and Saddam Hussein, were […]

  11. Two Stories of Torture in World War II - 2parse Says:

    […] I first started this blog, I told the story of two different interrogations at the beginning of Bush’s War on Terror – one using traditional methods which yielded actionable intelligence; and one using […]

  12. The Winklevoss Twins of Getting Bin Laden - 2parse by Joe Campbell Says:

    […] military and intelligence history were used to justify the Bush administration’s belief that Saddam and Bin Laden were working together on a WMD attack on America — and later, this same intelligence sources under torture, provided the basis for shutting […]

  13. mehmet Says:

    paylaşım için çok teşekkürler 🙂

  14. life quotes picures, life quote images, life quote photos Says:

    Hi my loved one! I want to say that this post is amazing, great written and come with almost all significant infos. I’d like to see more posts like this .

  15. jigsy.com Says:

    Thanks for sharing outstanding informations. Your web-site is
    really cool. I’m pleased by the details that you simply have on this web site. It reveals how nicely someone perceives this subject. Bookmarked this web page, will keep coming back for more articles. You, my pal, ROCK!

    Feel free to surf to my web blog :: fitness 19 health club [jigsy.com]

  16. Wenona Fraumann Says:

    Hello! This is my first visit to your blog! We are a collection of volunteers and starting a new initiative in a community in
    the same niche. Your blog provided us beneficial information to work on.
    You have done a marvellous job!

    Seht mal auf diesem Artikel Wenona Fraumann

  17. Best Acne Treatment Says:

    Nice post many thanks! We think your posts are excellent and hope there will be more soon.

    My web blog; Best Acne Treatment

  18. Best Garcinia Cambogia Says:

    Your style is so unique compared to other people I have read stuff from.
    Many thanks for posting when you’ve got the opportunity, Guess I’ll just book mark this site.

    Here is my website – Best Garcinia Cambogia

  19. Hermes Birkin Crocodile Celine Bag Replica Says:

    hermes kelly replica See This Website

Leave a Reply