Commentators and candidates have drawn many parallels from today’s Democratic candidates to historical figures and elections.
[via reddit]
[digg-reddit-me]Hillary Clinton has been described as Nixon and LBJ, including the latter by herself. John Edwards has been described as a FDR (mainly by himself), William Jennings Bryan and a Bobby Kennedy. Barack Obama’s historical analogues have been far-ranging. Ken Burns has compared Obama to Lincoln. David Horsey of the Seattle Post-Intelligencer has as well, as seen above. JFK’s top speechwriter has compared Obama to President Kennedy. Before his Iowa win, intelligent pundits saw parallels to failed liberal candidates: Adlai Stevenson, Bill Bradley, and Gene McCarthy.
But it wasn’t until Hillary took a swipe at Obama that the parallels to Barack to Martin Luther King, Jr. became evident. The main theme of the 2008 is, and will be, change. Americans know that we need to tackle many long-term issues:
- global climate change;
- radical islamism;
- the erosion of civil liberties;
- executive overreach;
- the instability of the American economy;
- globalization, the entitlement crises;
- health care reform;
- the inequality of opportunity and the rising gap between the rich and the poor.
Our current politics – based on tears and smears, on the Bushes and the Clintons, on money and more money – is unable to produce meaningful or lasting change.To vote for Clinton or Giuliani or Romney or Thompson or Huckabee (and to a lesser extent McCain ((The McCain of 1999 to 2002 could have changed politics. The McCain of today is still an honorable man – but despite his commendable honesty, I am not sure how much he would be able to, or willing to try to, get done.)) ) – is to vote to continue the politics of the past decades, producing gridlock and negligible progress, even as Cassandras continually point out our impending doom.
There are three candidates who embody three very different approaches to change: Ron Paul, Barack Obama, and John Edwards.
Ron Paul is quite clearly a reactionary – and in this case, I do not mean it to be derogatory. He wants to trim government to a radical extent – back to the period before the Civil War. I doubt the change he desires is possible – and, although I agree with his positions on many contemporary issues, I believe he goes too far in rejecting the American tradition after 1860. I believe there is much to criticize in the American tradition after the Civil War – but also great progress. Ron Paul’s opinions are a valued addition to the public debate.
It is easier to compare Barack Obama and John Edwards to each other, rather than to Paul. They agree on many policies and in their general themes. Their differences are about how they would lead us to the future – how they would accomplish change. When Hillary said that Barack was not Martin Luther King – it occurred to me that the movement he represents, and the figure he projects, recalls the relationship of Martin Luther King to John Edwards’s Malcolm X.
In many ways, the success of Obama is due to Edwards’s harassment of Clinton.
- Obama is trying to bring together people of varying political persuasions and to reach consensus on the major issues America faces. Edwards believes we must fight for them – by extreme measures if necessary.
- Obama calls on Americans to look past their race, gender, class, religion, and other social groupings to the values we share – to build on this consensus to achieve lasting change. Edwards calls on middle and lower class Americans to look to their self-interest, and to their children’s self-interest, and to be forceful in taking what they believe is their birthright.
- Obama focuses on community organizing, bringing new people into the process and the party, and convincing skeptics; Edwards focuses on rallying the base.
Anyone can see the relationship between Martin Luther King, Jr. and Malcolm X can see the parallels. (Which makes Clinton, unfortunately for her, LBJ again.)
Martin Luther King and Malcolm X’s disagreements about how to accomplish change were more fundamental than the current divide between Obama and Edwards; but both King and Malcolm X recognized in the other the same desire for change, and respected each other as individuals and as leaders. When I saw John Edwards defend Barack Obama against Clinton – this is what I thought of – not that the boys were ganging up on her as she suggested.
Martin Luther King succeeded where Malcolm X did not because King bet that he could bring achieve more by appealing to all Americans, rather than a select group. Barack has made a similar bet. While in King’s day, the Jim Crow laws divided Americans into blacks and whites, our politics today has divided America into Red States and Blue States, liberals and conservatives, Republicans and Democrats. We have been divided into two teams – we on our respective team, often without a clear rationale, adopt positions and defend our teams against all opposition. Many others are turned off from politics by the partisanship entirely. Yet polls show that agreement exists among working majorities on how to tackle some of our major long-term problems; and even larger portions of Americans agree that something must be done to attempt to deal with the major problems we will soon face.
Obama’s bet, like Martin Luther King, Jr.’s, is that with a respectful and intelligent dialogue, he can change our politics; and by changing politics, we can change America’s path together.
It is supremely unlikely that he, or we, can accomplish this. But we owe it to ourselves to try.
Related articles
1,282 replies on “A Dream Deeply Rooted in the American Dream”
Hello very cool web site!! Guy .. Beautiful .. Superb .. I’ll bookmark your website and take the feeds also…I am happy to seek out so many useful information here in the publish, we’d like work out more techniques in this regard, thanks for sharing. . . . . .
clock parts suppliers
Purchase a fantastic Large wall clock kits currently available and in stock and reasonably priced today only!
clock movement kit
locate a wonderful clock hands kit that are available and now in stock in addition reasonably priced today only!
bill mail service
locate professional assistance billing mailing services that is available and ready to go now and gets results today!
Printed Invoice Mailing Service
Purchase the professional automated billing services that’s available and ready to go now and gets results today!
online mail service
Buy professional assistance print and mailing services currently available and ready to start in addition gets results today!
printing and mailing services
Purchase the professional mail printing services that is available and ready to go now and gets you results today!
clock dials
locate a great best quality quartz clock movements currently available and in stock and currently available today only!
See More
Find here top Gas fire pit burner that’s available plus reasonably priced now!
Printed Invoice Mailing Service
Buy legal help statement printing services that is available and ready to start and gets results today!
replacement parts for battery operated clocks
Buy a fantastic clock parts currently available and now in stock and reasonably priced today only!
print and mailing services
locate the professional Towne Mailer currently available and ready to start and gets results today!
bill mail service
locate legal help get more info here currently available and ready to go now in addition gets you results today!
invoice mailing services
Purchase professional assistance Printed Invoice Mailing Service that’s available and ready to go now and gets results today!
basement finishing denver
Purchase a wonderful basement repair denver that are available and ready to start in addition reasonably priced today only!
basementology
locate a great denver basement finishing cost that are available and ready to start and at the best price today only!
Click Here
locate a wonderful See All that are available and ready to go now and reasonably priced today only!
gas fire pit tables
locate a great crossfire brass burner that is available and now in stock in addition reasonably priced today only!
statement printing services
Buy the professional bill printing services that is available and ready to go now in addition gets your life back today!
basement finishing colorado
Buy a fantastic basement contractor denver that are available and ready to start in addition at great prices today only!
basement finish denver
locate a fantastic Click Here that’s available and ready to go now in addition on sale today only!
crossfire brass burner
Purchase a wonderful warming trends gas burners that are available and now in stock in addition on sale today only!
high quality fire pits
locate a wonderful fire pit bowls that’s available and now in stock in addition at the best price today only!
replacement logs for gas fire pit
Buy a great Propane fire pit burner that is available and now in stock in addition at the best price today only!
gas fire pit burners
locate a great replacement logs for gas fire pit that are available and now in stock and on sale today only!
Propane fire pit burner
Buy a fantastic gas fire pit insert that’s available and in stock in addition reasonably priced today only!
denver basements
Purchase a great basement remodelers denver that is available and ready to go now in addition currently available today only!
Click Here
locate a fantastic basement finishers denver that is available and ready to go now and on sale today only!
warming trends dealers
locate a great high quality fire pits currently available and in stock in addition reasonably priced today only!
invoice mailing service
Buy the professional printing and mail services that’s available and ready to go now and gets you results today!
basement finishing parker co
Buy a fantastic affordable basements that is available and ready to go now in addition at great prices today only!
gas fire pit burners
locate a wonderful gas fire pit burners that are available and now in stock and at great prices today only!
Visit Now
Buy a great Gas fire pit burner that’s available and in stock in addition at the best price today only!
warming trends crossfire burner
See professional outdoor fire pit replacement parts that’s available in addition reasonably priced now!
basementology
Purchase a wonderful basements and beyond denver reviews that are available and ready to go now in addition at the best price today only!
how to finish a basement wall
Purchase a wonderful Affordable Basement Finishing Company that’s available and ready to start and currently available today only!
elkstone basements
Purchase a wonderful basement finishing aurora co that is available and ready to go now in addition currently available today only!
mail printing services
Buy the professional online invoice service currently available and ready to go now and gets your life back today!
basement contractor denver
locate a fantastic basement contractors denver that’s available and ready to go now and on sale today only!
denver basement remodel
Buy a wonderful basement finish denver co that is available and ready to go now and at the best price today only!
View More
Buy a fantastic replacement logs for gas fire pit that are available and in stock and reasonably priced today only!
fire pit tray
locate a fantastic Fire pit burners that are available and in stock and on sale today only!
Propane fire pit burner
locate a great Natural gas fire pit burners that is available and in stock and on sale today only!
warming trends fire pit burners
Purchase a fantastic Gas fire pit burner that is available and now in stock in addition at great prices today only!
finishing a basement ideas
locate a fantastic how to finish a basement wall currently available and ready to go now and at the best price today only!
Affordable Basement Finishing Company
locate a great basement contractors denver that are available and ready to start and on sale today only!
basements and beyond denver reviews
Purchase a wonderful basement contractor denver that is available and ready to go now in addition reasonably priced today only!
Printed Invoice Mailing Service
Buy legal help online invoicing services currently available and ready to start in addition gets you results today!
basement finishing cost calculator
Purchase a fantastic denver basement finishing that’s available and ready to go now in addition reasonably priced today only!
basements and beyond denver reviews
locate a fantastic basement finishing aurora co that is available and ready to go now and currently available today only!