Andrew Sullivan and Ezra Klein both posted today about Campbell’s Law, citing an article by Dana Goldstein in the Daily Beast about corruption in schools under Michelle Rhee’s chancellorship in Washington, D.C.:

In the social sciences, there is an oft-repeated maxim called Campbell’s Law, named after Donald Campbell, a psychologist who studied human creativity. Campbell’s Law states that incentives corrupt. In other words, the more punishments and rewards—such as merit pay—are associated with the results of any given test, the more likely it is that the test’s results will be rendered meaningless, either through outright cheating or through teaching to the test in a way that narrows the curriculum and renders real learning obsolete.

I can think of cooler things that might be called Campbell’s Law — but such as it is, it goes a long way to explaining the flaw in capitalism without enough regulation. Organizing an economy around the pursuit of currency is efficient but not in the way it was intended — as any shortcut or corruption is utilized, as every possible cost is externalized.

It also goes a helps explain — but not as completely — how government tax incentives subsidizing gasoline, corn, middle class mortgages, student loans, and health care costs has led to escalating demand for these resources — seemingly distorting the market more than a direct intervention would. There seems to be something about tax incentives that distorts markets more than direct interventions. (A topic that seems up Matt Yglesias‘s alley to explore.)

On a related note, when taxpayers demand their receipt for government services– it should reflect not only disbursements, but the cost of tax benefits and loopholes.

Andrew Sullivan and Ezra Klein both posted today about Campbell’s Law, citing an article by Dana Goldstein in the Daily Beast about corruption in schools under Michelle Rhee’s chancellorship in Washington, D.C.:

In the social sciences, there is an oft-repeated maxim called Campbell’s Law, named after Donald Campbell, a psychologist who studied human creativity. Campbell’s Law states that incentives corrupt. In other words, the more punishments and rewards—such as merit pay—are associated with the results of any given test, the more likely it is that the test’s results will be rendered meaningless, either through outright cheating or through teaching to the test in a way that narrows the curriculum and renders real learning obsolete.

I can think of cooler things that might be called Campbell’s Law — but such as it is, it goes a long way to explaining the flaw in capitalism without enough regulation. Organizing an economy around the pursuit of currency is efficient but not in the way it was intended — as any shortcut or corruption is utilized, as every possible cost is externalized.

It also goes a helps explain — but not as completely — how government tax incentives subsidizing gasoline, corn, middle class mortgages, student loans, and health care costs has led to escalating demand for these resources — seemingly distorting the market more than a direct intervention would. There seems to be something about tax incentives that distorts markets more than direct interventions. (A topic that seems up Matt Yglesias‘s alley to explore.)

On a related note, when taxpayers demand their receipt for government services– it should reflect not only disbursements, but the cost of tax benefits and loopholes.




Campbell’s Law


By Joe Campbell
March 30th, 2011

Andrew Sullivan and Ezra Klein both posted today about Campbell’s Law, citing an article by Dana Goldstein in the Daily Beast about corruption in schools under Michelle Rhee’s chancellorship in Washington, D.C.:

In the social sciences, there is an oft-repeated maxim called Campbell’s Law, named after Donald Campbell, a psychologist who studied human creativity. Campbell’s Law states that incentives corrupt. In other words, the more punishments and rewards—such as merit pay—are associated with the results of any given test, the more likely it is that the test’s results will be rendered meaningless, either through outright cheating or through teaching to the test in a way that narrows the curriculum and renders real learning obsolete.

I can think of cooler things that might be called Campbell’s Law — but such as it is, it goes a long way to explaining the flaw in capitalism without enough regulation. Organizing an economy around the pursuit of currency is efficient but not in the way it was intended — as any shortcut or corruption is utilized, as every possible cost is externalized.

It also goes a helps explain — but not as completely — how government tax incentives subsidizing gasoline, corn, middle class mortgages, student loans, and health care costs has led to escalating demand for these resources — seemingly distorting the market more than a direct intervention would. There seems to be something about tax incentives that distorts markets more than direct interventions. (A topic that seems up Matt Yglesias‘s alley to explore.)

On a related note, when taxpayers demand their receipt for government services– it should reflect not only disbursements, but the cost of tax benefits and loopholes.

Be Sociable, Share!

Tags: , , , , , ,

80 Responses to “Campbell’s Law”

  1. Monster World Hack Says:

    You Are Great Mai Really Your Website Has A Great info

  2. win the lottery subliminal cds Says:

    It is appropriate time to make some plans ffor the future and it is time to
    be happy. I’ve read this post and if I could I desire to
    suggest you few interesting thinfs or suggestions.
    Maybe you can write next articles referring to this article.

    I wish tto read even more thibgs about it!

    My blog; win the lottery subliminal cds

  3. music monitors Says:

    Definitely believe that that you said. Your favourite reason appeared
    to be at the internet tthe simplest thing to tae into accout of.
    I say to you, I definitely get irked aat the same time
    as other folks think about concerjs that they just doo
    not recognize about. You controllesd to hit the nail upon the highest annd also outlined out the whole thing without having
    side effect , folks can take a signal. Will likely be again to get more.
    Thanbk you

    my web blog music monitors

  4. Faith Says:

    Greate post. Keep posting such kind of information on your site.

    Im really impressed by it.
    Hi there, You have performed an excellent job.
    I will definitely digg it and personally suggest to my friends.
    I’m confident they will be benefited from this website.

  5. loss plan target Says:

    Why users still make use of to read news papers when in this technological globe
    all is accessible on web?

  6. Yelp Says:

    Hey there excellent website! Does running a blog
    like this require a lot of work? I’ve absolutely no understanding of coding but
    I had been hoping to start my own blog in the near future.

    Anyway, if you have any recommendations or tips
    for new blog owners please share. I know this
    is off topic but I simply wanted to ask. Cheers!

  7. cockroach baiting Says:

    Admiring the commitment you put into your website and detailed
    information you offer. It’s good to come across a blog every once
    in a while that isn’t the same out of date rehashed material.
    Great read! I’ve bookmarked your site and I’m including your RSS feeds to my Google account.

  8. Nila Says:

    This doesn’t appear to have ocurred with VAST.

  9. shovel knight in shining armor lyrics Says:

    If you have small children and want to visit an amusement park they can enjoy,
    check out Legoland California shovel knight in shining armor lyrics suburban San Diego.
    It was amazing that he can see in this dark and misty
    place. Aquarius as the rebellions spirit and trendsetter is forging ahead into
    new adventures.

  10. limo service edmonton rates Says:

    Innovation limousine company supplies the hottest and most classy limousines
    that Calgary, Edmonton and Red Deer need to offer.

  11. live gold prices kitco Says:

    Gold is taken into account a secure haven over stock markets as
    stock markets fall ‘out of favour’.

  12. themes for bootstrap Says:

    You possibly can visit the net freelance writing jobs websites and
    set up a free profile and begin on the lookout for work that
    approach.

  13. paleo diet meal plan Says:

    Advocates of paleo weight loss program eat meals which have much less salt,
    less carbs, more fiber and rather more protein.

  14. nefful negative ion clothing malaysia Says:

    It’ll produce a sort of shield around you that will aid to safeguard you
    from terrible air.

  15. fitbit aria setup guest Says:

    This kind of workout group comes with an easy to use sports cardio belt, which enhances effectiveness and the security of
    an individual.

  16. ciao bella t-shirt Says:

    Argyle is in style for little girls this winter, making a statement on sweaters, pleated 60’s skirts and flared pants.

  17. vinyl siding norwalk ct Says:

    The company then sells the knowledge to 3-5 contractors who then name the
    client and try to win the job.

  18. export to russia from canada Says:

    The United States offered lower than 1 p.c of Russia’s pork imports in 2013,
    although in 2012 it was 12 %.

  19. bayswater physiotherapy hervey bay Says:

    Our practice is absolutely computerised and has amassed a huge
    vary of native and on-line clinical assist resources for both sufferers and docs.

  20. wie kann ich schnell abnehmen tipps Says:

    Wer meint, dass der das Lebensmittel noch , wenn man möglichst viel isst genauso falsch wie der that is wird, der zu.

  21. synthetic dreadlock extensions tutorial Says:

    After completing the Dome Academy four day foundation course he became a professional stylist in Monofibre® extensions.

  22. beverly hills financial advisors Says:

    Learn how our skilled financial advisors can assist you get the place you want
    to go.

  23. dilwale songs youtube Says:

    Hey There. I found your weblog using msn. That is a very neatly
    written article. I’ll be sure to bookmark it and come back to read
    extra of your useful info. Thank you for the post. I will definitely return.

  24. homepage Says:

    The PLAN is also readying an air wing and escorts for the vessel The navy
    possesses two Kind 052C destroyers armed with lengthy-range anti-aircraft missiles.

  25. victorino noval instagram Says:

    Noval mentioned he invited buddies and neighbors
    to satisfy Jackson for a fundraiser earlier this yr at his $6.1-million residence in Beverly
    Hills.

  26. online appointment scheduling freeware Says:

    Customers not merely appreciate reminders, they are
    able to also help to keep their appointment slots loaded by
    decreasing the “no-show” price.

  27. tarotista bueno y economico Says:

    What’s up i am kavin, its my first time to commenting anyplace, whe i read this paragraph
    i thought i could also create comment due to
    this good article.

  28. pa programs in ny state Says:

    The programs are operated independently; admissions, curriculum, and so on., are all distinct among the packages.

  29. good and cheap seer Says:

    I’m no longer certain where you’re getting your information,
    but good topic. I must spend a while learning more or understanding more.
    Thank you for magnificent info I was searching for this information for my mission.

  30. call of roma / caesary ultra hack Says:

    In 2010, after the earthquake occurred in Haiti, lots of the official communication strains were down.

  31. usaa new construction Says:

    USAA wouldn’t conform to them, regardless of the COL inspection outcomes, and solely
    50% of the associated fee at that.

  32. Find Out More Says:

    If the water injury arises from a flood, for instance, it
    may nnot saturate the wall.

  33. visit here Says:

    The electrical permitttivity is related tto the power saved
    in an electric discipline.

  34. Florrie Says:

    Echar en la olla un fondo de aceite y poner al fuego, cuando está bien caliente agregar el pollo ya
    limpio y con la piel.

  35. global server time Says:

    Lets take into account, a customer is looking from US, in usual hosting ,
    this request can be despatched straight to the server where
    it is hosted, and the request could be served from the UK server solely.

  36. cardiologue salaire suisse Says:

    Le generaliste l a envoye plus tard chez le cardiologue faire
    un electrocardiogramme de 24 h qui n a rien revele non plus.

  37. ebay seller training Says:

    Ask every participant to create one or two action plans
    that pertains to the training. Administer quizzes or incorporate issues
    to solve throughout the training to test for understanding.

  38. dentist chef menteur Says:

    Katie is a normal dentist in a big group observe in Katy, Texas
    (a fast 25 minute commute from Houston).

  39. c240130085379535303 Says:

    Obsidian White Noise Gordo is my after dinner, sit back and
    calm down within the yard cigar.

  40. industrial machine vision camera Says:

    Other causes are a bent needle, machine out of time, a
    unfastened pressure foot, or the plate under the strain foot has turn out
    to be unfastened. DALIAN, China In a cavernous showroom on the outskirts of this port metropolis in northeastern China, softly whirring lathes and
    svelte robot arms symbolize Dalian Machine Instruments Group’s (DMTG) vision of an automated future for Chinese
    language manufacturing.

  41. investment casting ppt Says:

    Price of return is the gain or loss made by an investment or a enterprise
    as a whole, expressed as a percentage. Ratio evaluation is to make use of the various ratios
    that assist evaluate the efficiency of the corporate with other companies, or with its previous
    results or for checking inner effectivity. Realizable value is the value that is expected on changing the belongings held by
    the company to money. This tells us how a company is doing in relation to the number of shares it has.

  42. c4494104276406165164 Says:

    I requested a love spell and, amazingly, it labored!

  43. business plan template Says:

    In all the conditions talked about above, one should write the letter in an expert method.
    The under template can be utilized as a guide while writing the letter.

  44. eye illness in dogs Says:

    Corneal ulcers cause ache and discomfort and
    most pets start to squint or cry as a result of ache. There could also be
    seen redness and inflammation inside and across the eye.

  45. bahamas customs form c2a Says:

    Bahamian businessmen and women observe the customs of the American and Europeans
    in gown.

  46. real estate indonesia yogyakarta Says:

    Nonetheless, the standard householders insurance coverage coverage does lengthen insurance coverage advantages initially and upon dying of the decedent-insured to
    the authorized consultant (i.e., executor or administrator) of such insured through
    the interim interval present submit-dying and pre-distribution to the last word beneficiary (i.e.,
    whereas an executor or administrator is probating / administering the Estate).
    Before you cash in from your inheritance of your Property be ready
    to pay taxes.

  47. best design websites university Says:

    The typefaces you choose and kinds you employ can converse volumes
    about the remainder of the design.

  48. justin bieber what do you mean album Says:

    Justin‘s mother gave delivery to him when she was simply
    17 and his dad Jeremy Bieber was 18. Justin Bieber is off formal
    probation in his infamous egg throwing case.

  49. recipes with ground turkey meat Says:

    Technique: Sprinkle salt and pepper on the salmon.

  50. espresso powder at walmart Says:

    A particular feature of espresso, as opposed to brewed coffee, is espresso’s association with cafés, due both to the specialised equipment and skill
    required, thus making the enjoyment of espresso a social expertise.
    Right this moment, a wide range of residence espresso tools will be found in kitchen and appliance stores,
    online vendors, and department shops. This technique makes for a smaller, more intense drink — something that many coffee drinkers desire.

  51. videography tips dslr Says:

    So in some circumstances, the one who you communicate with when signing your contract
    won’t really be the one taking pictures your wedding.
    Many instances, a second shooter comes with the videography bundle,
    but simply in case, it is good to ask.

  52. money management apps for pc Says:

    In this administration type, decisions and insurance
    policies are made as regards to charts and variables.

  53. top travel sites in india Says:

    Nice record — hope to be on it in 2011 (must get A game on!).

  54. c6019130695513902084 Says:

    Shiraz Shisha provides high quality Hookah providers in a comfy and trendy lounge.

  55. the immortal life of henrietta lacks summary chapter 3 Says:

    Do not forget to live your life as you climb that ladder…
    no matter all the universal unknowns.

  56. crazy taxi driver in istanbul Says:

    Then the driving force surprise me by : i
    should change the best way due to the traffic !

  57. books of the bible in spanish Says:

    Although many within the Protestant denomination might not give the Apocrypha much thought,
    others query as to whether authorities” made the suitable call in eradicating the books.

  58. green tea extract walmart Says:

    Inexperienced tea(matcha) into the mixture.

  59. c5603015286793458030 Says:

    At TED conferences and TEDx occasions, leading thinkers
    and doers are asked to present the speak of their lives in 18 minutes or less.

  60. speeding ticket california insurance Says:

    States can differ wildly on how aggressively they monitor the roads, how harshly they punish speeding offenses, and how exhausting
    it is to battle a ticket.

  61. c4594645391094487236 Says:

    Navigate to Zamzar for a web site method of getting your music.

  62. tv shows tonight on fox Says:

    Only a few shows are really profitable at fully serialized storytelling, and I
    feel the entire pattern in the direction of placating the “binge viewing” will run its course and burn itself out.

  63. real estate investing Says:

    A newly licensed vendor can also be required to take 30 hours
    of continuing actual estate schooling inside the first two years.

  64. vegetarian chili mac Says:

    Vegetarian eating regimen primarily includes grains, nuts,
    cereals, seeds, beans, greens, and fruits.

  65. disney world map Says:

    This limited level-to-point service had imagineers create a complete
    new poster to replicate the new route of the Walt Disney World
    Railroad!!

  66. now tv service hotline Says:

    The service launch comes as Comcast continues to add Internet
    subscribers whereas dropping TV subscriptions.

  67. violin cover love songs Says:

    Whereas his discography was never enormous, he nonetheless made an exquisite contribution to
    twentieth century American classical music.

  68. c3386693214877570560 Says:

    Music generally served as a background both when folks chose to
    take heed to it and when then did not select to hearken to it.

    The primary reply as to why individuals listened to music
    was that it was for enjoyment and that it helped go the time.

  69. post3752676 Says:

    Depression is more frequent among girls than amongst men.

  70. c2646668950108675226 Says:

    What actually separates The Man in the Machine from most other Jobs biographies is its layered strategy
    to the film’s topic. For the file; the video crashed simply before last
    acceptance.

  71. new york cheap places to stay Says:

    Don’t miss out on these spectacular NYC tour offers!

  72. c8285097566732418329 Says:

    Nevertheless, they give you a number of possibilities to do
    surveys so in case you are screened out of 1, you may strive your luck at another
    2 or three. Good for those who believe ‘endurance is a advantage’.
    They provide you a £1 Bonusbond voucher for each survey completed, which can be used in loads of excessive road retailers and on-line.
    I agree that you simply positively want to enroll to a couple to actually start earning some good money.

  73. word document automation docvariable Says:

    As soon as our highly expert automation team have automated your
    documents we will provide your users with the training required to ensure they get probably the most
    out of the system and realise all its advantages.

  74. Binäre Optionen Says:

    It’s remarkable to pay a quick visit this site and reading
    the views of all friends regarding this paragraph, while I am also zealous of
    getting familiarity.

  75. c6824547263289348179 Says:

    As you’ll be able to see, there are a myriad of explanation why chances
    are you’ll want our help in buying your home, however
    no matter your distinctive scenario is, we are able to make one
    assure; When we buy your home, we’ll do it ethically & efficiently, and we are
    going to solely do a take care of you if all events win.

  76. festivals in florida november 2015 Says:

    Thanks for the article, in a world crammed with festivals this is a useful resource.

  77. black magic woman fleetwood mac Says:

    Meaning that at the same time as strong as Hellmaster and Dynast are, they can not solid a Dragon Slave or any spells of other
    Lords without killing themselves within the course of.

  78. business consulting jobs denver co Says:

    On occasion, Worldwide Higher Education Consulting Blog
    will put up thought frightening items to problem readers and to encourage comment and professional dialogue.

  79. online advertising manager jobs uk Says:

    A writer will discover that setting a fee card at a stage low enough to promote out the bulk
    of the inventory will improve retention for advertisers and drive up charges in the long run.

  80. technology in the classroom good or bad Says:

    This adult gorilla uses a department as a strolling keep on with gauge the water’s depth,
    an instance of technology utilization by non-human primates.

Leave a Reply